In recent years, there has been an increasing overlap between the fields of industrial design and copyright law. This interface raises several legal and practical challenges, including the determination of the scope of protection, the evaluation of originality and novelty, and the identification of infringement. As such, it has become a topic of great relevance for scholars, practitioners, and policymakers alike.
Industrial design refers to the ornamental or aesthetic aspects of a product, such as its shape, pattern, or colour. It plays a critical role in enhancing the functionality, usability, and attractiveness of products, thereby contributing to their commercial success. Copyright law, on the other hand, protects the expression of original ideas in tangible forms, such as literary, artistic, musical, and other creative works. It serves as a powerful tool for creators to control and monetize their intellectual creations, as well as for society to promote cultural diversity and innovation.
7 Important Intellectual Property Rights in India
The purpose of this article is to provide a comparative study of the interface between industrial design and copyright law. Specifically, it aims to analyze the conceptual and practical overlaps between these two fields, compare the legal frameworks for industrial design and copyright protection in selected countries, and evaluate the opportunities and challenges of their interface. By doing so, this article seeks to contribute to a better understanding of the complex and dynamic relationship between industrial design and copyright law, and provide insights for future policy and practice.
Table of Contents
Industrial Design
Industrial design protection is an important aspect of the legal framework for designers and manufacturers. The protection of industrial design is typically achieved through intellectual property rights, including patents, trademarks, and copyrights. The legal framework for industrial design protection varies from country to country, but there are several international treaties and agreements that provide a framework for the protection of industrial design at the international level.
One of the most important international treaties in this regard is the Hague Agreement Concerning the International Deposit of Industrial Designs, which provides a system for the international registration of industrial designs. This agreement allows designers and manufacturers to register their designs in multiple countries through a single application process, simplifying the process of obtaining protection for industrial designs.
At the national level, the protection of industrial design is typically governed by copyright and design laws. Copyright law protects the visual and artistic aspects of industrial designs, such as the shape, colour, and texture of a product, while design law protects the functional aspects of industrial designs, such as the way a product is used or works.
In many countries, industrial design protection is governed by a combination of copyright and design laws. For example, in the United Kingdom, industrial designs are protected under both copyright law and the Design Patent Act, which provides protection for new, original, and ornamental designs for articles of manufacture.
In other countries, such as India and Brazil, industrial designs are protected under separate design laws, which provide protection for the aesthetic aspects of industrial designs, as well as their functionality. Overall, the legal framework for industrial design protection is complex and varies widely from country to country. However, by understanding the international and national legal frameworks for industrial design protection, designers and manufacturers can ensure that their products are adequately protected and can benefit from the commercial and financial advantages that come with creating unique and innovative industrial designs.
Copyright Law
Copyright law is a legal framework that grants creators of original works exclusive rights to use, reproduce, distribute, and display their works for a certain period of time. The scope of copyright law is broad, covering works of art, literature, music, software, architecture, and other creative works. Copyright law aims to promote creativity and innovation by providing legal protection to creators’ works.
Copyright law has its roots in the Statute of Anne, which was enacted in England in 1710. The Statute of Anne established the first modern copyright law, providing authors with exclusive rights to their works for a period of 14 years, with the possibility of a 14-year extension. The concept of copyright law then spread to other countries, including the United States, where the first copyright law was enacted in 1790.
Over time, copyright law has undergone significant changes to keep up with technological advancements and changing social norms. The most significant of these changes was the adoption of the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works in 1886. The Convention established the principles of automatic copyright protection and the principle of national treatment, meaning that each country must grant the same level of copyright protection to works originating from other countries as it does to its own works.
Copyright law plays an important role in promoting creativity and innovation by providing legal protection to creators’ works. By granting exclusive rights to creators, copyright law incentivizes innovation and creativity by providing them with a means to monetize their works. This, in turn, promotes economic growth and cultural diversity. It serves as a mechanism for regulating the use of creative works, ensuring that they are not used without the creator’s consent or in a manner that undermines their value. It also serves as a means of preserving cultural heritage by protecting traditional works of art and cultural expressions from being exploited or misused.
Copyright law is a subject of both national and international legal frameworks. The primary international treaty governing copyright law is the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works. The Berne Convention sets out the basic principles of copyright law, such as the minimum duration of copyright protection, the rights granted to creators, and the limitations and exceptions to those rights.
You can read the article about What is copyright?
National copyright laws also often include specific provisions for protecting industrial designs, such as through design patents or industrial design rights. These provisions are designed to protect the visual appearance and ornamental aspects of functional objects, such as furniture, cars, and electronics, which are often the subject of industrial design.
The interface between Industrial Design and Copyright Law
The relationship between industrial design and copyright law is complex and multifaceted, with conceptual and practical overlaps that can create legal ambiguities and controversies. This section will provide a comparative study of industrial design and copyright protection criteria, explore the case law and legal controversies surrounding the interface between industrial design and copyright law, and discuss the opportunities and challenges of this interface.
Industrial design and copyright law both deal with the protection of creative works, but they approach this protection from different angles. Industrial design focuses on the protection of the aesthetic and functional aspects of a product, while copyright law focuses on the protection of original works of authorship.
The “aesthetic” aspects of a product are protected by industrial design law, which allows designers to register their designs and prevent others from using or copying them without permission. Industrial design law aims to encourage innovation and creativity in product design and to protect the investments of designers in their designs.[i]
Copyright law, on the other hand, protects original works of authorship, such as literary, musical, and artistic works. This protection extends to the reproduction, distribution, and display of the work, as well as to derivative works based on the original.
Industrial design protection criteria differ from copyright protection criteria in several ways. While copyright protection requires originality, industrial design protection requires novelty and uniqueness. Additionally, industrial design protection is limited to the visual appearance of a product, while copyright protection can extend to the underlying ideas and concepts expressed in a work. Industrial design protection is also limited in duration, typically lasting for a period of 10 to 25 years, while copyright protection can last for the lifetime of the author plus 70 years.
The interface between industrial design and copyright law provides both opportunities and challenges for designers and companies. On the one hand, industrial design protection can help designers to establish and protect their brand identity and to create unique and innovative products that stand out in the marketplace. On the other hand, copyright protection can help companies to protect their intellectual property and to prevent others from copying their works.[ii]
However, the interface between industrial design and copyright law also creates challenges, such as legal ambiguities and uncertainties, as well as the difficulty of determining when a design is functional and therefore ineligible for copyright protection, the interface between industrial design and copyright law is complex and multifaceted, with both opportunities and challenges for designers and companies. It requires a careful balancing of the need for the protection of creative works with the need to encourage innovation and competition in the marketplace.
Comparative Study
A comparative study of industrial design and copyright law in selected countries can provide valuable insights into the similarities and differences between legal frameworks and criteria for protection. This section will analyze national and international legal frameworks for industrial design and copyright protection, evaluate industrial design and copyright law criteria in selected countries, and provide case studies on the intersection between industrial design and copyright law.
National legal frameworks for industrial design and copyright protection vary widely across countries, with differences in the scope of protection, criteria for protection, and duration of protection. Some countries, such as the United States, have separate legal regimes for industrial design and copyright protection, while others, such as the European Union, have integrated legal frameworks for both types of protection.[iii]
International legal frameworks, such as the Hague Agreement Concerning the International Deposit of Industrial Designs and the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works, provide minimum standards of protection for industrial design and copyright, respectively. However, these international agreements do not provide uniform protection across all countries and do not resolve all legal ambiguities and controversies that can arise at the intersection between industrial design and copyright law.
The criteria for protection of industrial design and copyright law vary across countries and legal frameworks. For example, the United States requires industrial designs to be “new and non-obvious”, while the European Union requires industrial designs to have “individual character”. Copyright protection requires originality in most countries, but the scope of protection can differ, with some countries providing narrower protection for functional works.
Comparative study of industrial design and copyright law in selected countries can provide valuable insights into the similarities and differences between legal frameworks and criteria for protection, as well as the legal ambiguities and controversies that can arise at the intersection between these two areas of law.
Conclusion
This article has explored the interface between industrial design and copyright law, providing a conceptual and practical analysis of the overlaps between these two areas of law, a comparative evaluation of their protection criteria, and case studies on their intersection in selected countries.
The main findings of this article are that industrial design and copyright law share similarities and differences in their criteria for protection, duration of protection, and legal frameworks across countries. While industrial design law is focused on protecting the functional and aesthetic aspects of a product, copyright law is focused on protecting original works of authorship, which can include some functional works. The intersection between these two areas of law can create legal ambiguities and controversies, which are addressed differently across countries and legal frameworks.
The implications and recommendations for policy and practice include the need for clearer legal frameworks, criteria for protection, and standards for determining when a design is functional and when it is eligible for copyright protection. This can be achieved through greater harmonization of national and international legal frameworks and through interdisciplinary collaboration between industrial designers and legal experts.
Limitations of this article include the focus on selected countries and legal frameworks, which may not represent the diversity of legal systems across the world. Future research directions could include a more comprehensive analysis of national and international legal frameworks, a deeper exploration of the conceptual and practical overlaps between industrial design and copyright law, and empirical studies of the impact of legal frameworks on innovation, creativity, and economic growth.
In conclusion, this article provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the interface between industrial design and copyright law, highlighting the need for greater clarity and harmonization of legal frameworks and criteria for protection, and for interdisciplinary collaboration between industrial designers and legal experts.
Written By- Arghya Sen,
2nd Year Ballb, Amity University, Kolkata
References
[i] What is an industrial design? (no date) Frequently asked questions: Industrial designs. Available at: https://www.wipo.int/designs/en/faq_industrialdesigns.html#:~:text=An%20industrial%20design%20right%20protects,functional%20features%20of%20a%20product. (Accessed: March 20, 2023).
[ii] Module 2 Trademarks and Industrial Designs – WIPO (no date) WIPO. Available at: https://www.wipo.int/export/sites/www/sme/en/documents/pdf/ip_panorama_2_learning_points.pdf (Accessed: March 20, 2023).
[iii] Industrial Design Protection (no date) Internal Market, Industry, Entrepreneurship and SMEs. Available at: https://single-market-economy.ec.europa.eu/industry/strategy/intellectual-property/industrial-design-protection_en (Accessed: March 20, 2023).